Critical Illness

Critical Illness Claims Process: Step-by-Step Guide

Your Home Finance Team
14 min read
20 November 2024

Critical Illness Claims Process: Step-by-Step Guide

Making a critical illness claim can feel overwhelming when you're already dealing with a serious diagnosis. Understanding the claims process before you need it helps ensure a smooth, successful claim when the time comes. This comprehensive guide walks you through every step.

Overview: What to Expect

Typical Claims Timeline

Standard claim (no complications):

  • Notification to initial assessment: 1-3 days
  • Medical evidence gathering: 2-6 weeks
  • Decision: 1-2 weeks after evidence received
  • Payment: 3-5 working days after approval
  • Total time: 4-10 weeks

Complex claim (additional evidence needed):

  • As above, plus:
  • Specialist reports requested: 4-8 weeks
  • Independent medical examination: 2-4 weeks
  • Additional investigations: 2-8 weeks
  • Total time: 3-6 months

Disputed claim:

  • Initial decline: After evidence review
  • Appeal submitted: Your timeline
  • Appeal review: 4-8 weeks
  • Financial Ombudsman (if needed): 6-12 months
  • Total time: 6-18+ months

Key Success Factors

Early notification - Tell insurer as soon as diagnosed
Complete disclosure - Provide all requested information
Medical evidence - Ensure diagnosis meets policy definition
Timely responses - Reply to insurer requests quickly
Accurate records - Keep copies of all correspondence
Professional support - Use adviser if claim complex

Step 1: Understanding Policy Definitions

Before making a claim, verify your condition meets the policy definition.

Common Critical Illnesses and Their Definitions

Cancer

Typical policy definition:

"A malignant tumour characterised by the uncontrolled growth and spread of malignant cells and the invasion of tissue. The term malignant tumour includes leukaemia, sarcoma, lymphoma and Hodgkin's disease."

Usually excluded:

  • Carcinoma in situ (pre-cancerous, Stage 0)
  • Basal cell carcinoma (skin cancer)
  • Squamous cell carcinoma under 2cm (small skin cancer)
  • Early stage prostate cancer (TNM classification T1a or T1b, Gleason score 6 or below)
  • Chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (stage 0 or A, Binet staging)

Example:

Sarah, 42, diagnosed with DCIS (ductal carcinoma in situ) in breast:

  • DCIS is Stage 0 breast cancer (pre-invasive)
  • Policy definition requires invasive malignant cancer
  • DCIS does not meet definition
  • Claim declined (correct decision under policy terms)

After treatment:

  • If DCIS progresses to invasive breast cancer: Would meet definition
  • If surgery removes all DCIS and no invasive cancer: No claim possible

Key point: Check exact cancer diagnosis and staging against policy definition before claiming.

Heart Attack

Typical policy definition:

"Death of heart muscle due to inadequate blood supply that has resulted in all of the following evidence of acute myocardial infarction:

  1. New characteristic electrocardiographic (ECG) changes
  2. The characteristic rise of cardiac enzymes or Troponins
  3. Typical chest pain"

Usually excluded:

  • Angina (chest pain from insufficient blood flow, but no heart muscle death)
  • Elevation of cardiac biomarkers alone (without ECG changes or symptoms)
  • Non-ST segment elevation myocardial infarction (NSTEMI) if policy older (some modern policies do cover)

Example:

John, 58, chest pain, admitted to hospital:

  • Troponin levels elevated (indicating heart muscle damage)
  • ECG shows changes consistent with heart attack
  • Typical chest pain experienced
  • Diagnosis: Acute myocardial infarction
  • All three criteria met: ✓ ECG changes, ✓ Troponin rise, ✓ Chest pain
  • Claim approved

Counter-example:

David, 52, chest pain during exercise stress test:

  • Troponin levels normal
  • ECG shows ST-segment depression (indicates angina, not heart attack)
  • Chest pain present
  • Diagnosis: Angina, not heart attack
  • Criteria not met (no Troponin rise, no heart muscle death)
  • Claim declined (correct - angina excluded from standard policies)

Stroke

Typical policy definition:

"Cerebrovascular accident producing neurological sequelae lasting at least 24 hours. This includes infarction of brain tissue, intracranial and/or subarachnoid haemorrhage. There must be permanent neurological deficits with persisting clinical symptoms."

Usually excluded:

  • Transient ischaemic attack (TIA) - symptoms resolve within 24 hours
  • Traumatic injury to brain
  • Stroke without permanent symptoms

Key point: "Permanent" typically means symptoms lasting at least 24 hours. Some policies require longer (weeks to months).

Example:

Margaret, 67, sudden weakness right side, speech difficulty:

  • CT scan confirms ischaemic stroke (blood clot in brain)
  • Symptoms persist after 24 hours
  • 6 weeks post-stroke: Partial right-side weakness remains, speech slightly slurred
  • Permanent neurological deficit confirmed
  • Claim approved

Counter-example:

Robert, 55, sudden numbness left arm, difficulty speaking:

  • Initially thought to be stroke
  • Symptoms completely resolve after 3 hours
  • MRI shows no brain damage
  • Diagnosis: TIA (transient ischaemic attack)
  • No permanent neurological deficit
  • Claim declined (TIA excluded)

Multiple Sclerosis

Typical policy definition:

"A definite diagnosis of multiple sclerosis by a consultant neurologist confirmed by typical MRI findings and neurological abnormalities persisting for at least 6 months."

Requirements:

  • Diagnosis by specialist (neurologist)
  • MRI evidence
  • Symptoms persisting 6+ months

Example:

Emma, 38, experiencing vision problems, numbness:

  • MRI shows multiple lesions in brain and spinal cord
  • Neurologist diagnoses relapsing-remitting MS
  • Symptoms persist for 7 months
  • Further MRI confirms progression
  • All criteria met
  • Claim approved

Waiting period consideration:

  • Diagnosed month 1
  • Must wait until month 6+ to claim
  • Some insurers require evidence of progression or second relapse
  • Check specific policy wording

Step 2: Notification of Claim

Notify insurer as soon as diagnosis confirmed - don't delay.

How to Notify

Option 1: Telephone (Fastest)

Call the claims number:

  • Found in policy documents
  • Often 24/7 dedicated claims line
  • Speak directly with claims handler

What you'll need:

  • Policy number
  • Your name and address
  • Details of diagnosis
  • Date of diagnosis
  • Treating hospital/consultant name

What happens:

  • Claims handler opens your file
  • Asks preliminary questions
  • Explains process and timescales
  • Sends claim forms within 24-48 hours

Example call:

You: "I need to make a critical illness claim. I've been diagnosed with bowel cancer."
Handler: "I'm sorry to hear that. Let me help you. Can I take your policy number please?"
You: "It's L&G123456789."
Handler: "Thank you. Can you confirm your full name and date of birth?"
You: "Sarah Johnson, 15th March 1982."
Handler: "And when were you diagnosed?"
You: "Last Tuesday, 12th November, following a colonoscopy."
Handler: "Which hospital are you being treated at?"
You: "Royal Marsden Hospital. My oncologist is Dr. Michael Carter."
Handler: "Thank you Sarah. I've opened a claim for you. I'll email you claim forms today. You'll need to provide written consent for us to contact your doctors. I'll also send you information about our support services. Is there anything you need immediately?"

Option 2: Online

Most insurers now offer online claims submission:

  • Log into customer portal
  • Click "Make a claim"
  • Complete online form
  • Upload supporting documents
  • Receive acknowledgement immediately

Advantages:

  • Submit 24/7
  • Attach documents immediately
  • Automatic confirmation
  • Track progress online

Option 3: Via Your Adviser

If you used a financial adviser to arrange cover:

Benefits of adviser support:

  • They handle paperwork
  • Chase progress on your behalf
  • Ensure all information provided correctly
  • Act as intermediary with insurer
  • No cost (adviser already paid via commission)

Process:

  • Contact your adviser
  • They notify insurer on your behalf
  • Coordinator throughout claims process
  • Particularly valuable if claim complex or disputed

What Happens After Notification

Within 24-48 hours:

  1. Claims handler assigned to your case
  2. Acknowledgement letter/email sent
  3. Claim forms sent (or accessible online)
  4. Initial guidance provided

Claim reference number issued:

  • Use this in all correspondence
  • Needed when calling for updates
  • Helps track your claim

Step 3: Completing Claim Forms

Claim forms gather essential information about your diagnosis and circumstances.

Standard Information Required

Personal Information

  • Full name and address
  • Date of birth
  • National Insurance number
  • Contact details (phone, email)
  • Employment details

Policy Information

  • Policy number
  • Start date of policy
  • Premium payment confirmation
  • Any changes to policy since start

Medical Information

  • Diagnosis: Exact medical diagnosis
  • Date of diagnosis: When formally diagnosed
  • Symptoms: When symptoms first appeared
  • Treatment: Hospital, consultant, GP
  • Current status: Ongoing treatment, prognosis
  • Other medical history: Relevant health history

Consent Forms

  • GP records: Authorisation to access your GP records
  • Hospital records: Access to hospital notes and test results
  • Consultant reports: Permission to contact specialists
  • Ongoing updates: Consent for ongoing information requests

Financial Information

  • Other insurance: Any other critical illness or life policies
  • Payment details: Bank account for claim payout (if approved)

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Incomplete forms - Fill in every section or write "N/A" if not applicable
Delayed submission - Don't sit on forms for weeks
Missing signatures - Unsigned forms will be returned
Wrong diagnosis date - Provide actual diagnosis date, not first symptoms
Incomplete medical details - Include all relevant information

Example: Completing Medical Information Section

Question: "Please provide details of your diagnosis."

Bad answer:

"Cancer"

Why bad: Too vague. Doesn't specify type, stage, or confirming tests.

Good answer:

"Invasive ductal carcinoma of the right breast, diagnosed 15th November 2024 via core needle biopsy following abnormal mammogram on 28th October 2024. Histology confirmed ER+/PR+/HER2- invasive cancer, Grade 2, Stage 2A (T2N0M0). Oncologist: Dr Sarah Matthews, Royal Marsden Hospital. Treatment plan: Lumpectomy scheduled 3rd December 2024, followed by adjuvant chemotherapy and radiation therapy."

Why good:

  • Specific cancer type
  • Exact diagnosis date
  • Method of diagnosis
  • Staging information
  • Treating consultant and hospital
  • Treatment plan

This level of detail helps claim assessor immediately understand your condition and whether it meets policy definition.

Step 4: Medical Evidence Gathering

Insurer requests medical evidence from your healthcare providers.

What Evidence Is Requested?

GP Records

What's included:

  • Complete medical history
  • Past consultations
  • Chronic conditions
  • Medication history
  • Referral letters
  • Historical health issues

Timeline: Usually available within 2-4 weeks

Purpose:

  • Verify diagnosis
  • Check for pre-existing conditions (if relevant to policy contestability)
  • Understand full health picture

Hospital Records

What's included:

  • Admission notes
  • Discharge summaries
  • Test results (blood, imaging, pathology)
  • Surgical reports
  • Treatment plans

Timeline: 3-6 weeks (hospitals often slower than GPs)

Purpose:

  • Confirm diagnosis
  • Verify severity
  • Check policy definition criteria met

Specialist Reports

What's included:

  • Consultation notes
  • Diagnostic findings
  • Staging information (for cancer)
  • Prognosis
  • Treatment recommendations

Timeline: 2-6 weeks

Purpose:

  • Expert confirmation of diagnosis
  • Detailed condition assessment
  • Confirm policy definition requirements

Diagnostic Test Results

Depending on condition:

Cancer:

  • Biopsy reports
  • Pathology reports
  • Imaging (CT, MRI, PET scans)
  • Staging investigations

Heart Attack:

  • ECG results
  • Cardiac enzyme/Troponin levels
  • Angiogram results
  • Echocardiogram

Stroke:

  • CT or MRI scans
  • Neurological examination findings
  • Evidence of permanent deficit

MS:

  • MRI scans showing lesions
  • Evoked potential tests
  • Spinal fluid analysis (if performed)

Your Role in Evidence Gathering

What you can do to speed up process:

  1. Inform your doctors:

    • Tell GP and consultants about claim
    • Explain insurer will request records
    • Provide claim reference number
  2. Sign consent forms immediately:

    • Don't delay returning consent forms
    • Without consent, nothing can be requested
    • Common cause of delays
  3. Follow up with providers:

    • After 2-3 weeks, call GP surgery: "Has [insurer name] requested my records yet?"
    • If yes: "When will they be sent?"
    • Chase hospital records department if needed
  4. Provide copies if you have them:

    • Discharge summaries
    • Test results given to you
    • Consultant letters
    • Helps claim progress while awaiting official records

Typical Evidence Timeline

WeekActivity
Week 0Diagnosis, claim notified
Week 1Claim forms completed and returned
Week 1-2Insurer sends evidence requests to medical providers
Week 2-4GP records received
Week 3-6Hospital records received
Week 4-8Specialist reports received
Week 6-10All evidence compiled, claim assessed
Week 8-12Decision made and communicated
Week 8-13Payment issued (if approved)

Note: This is best-case scenario. Delays in medical records can extend timeline significantly.

Step 5: Claim Assessment

Claims assessor reviews all evidence against policy terms.

What the Assessor Checks

1. Policy is Active and Premiums Current

Checks:

  • Policy in force on diagnosis date
  • All premiums paid up to date
  • No lapse in cover
  • Policy not cancelled

Example issue:

Michael's heart attack:

  • Diagnosed: 15th November 2024
  • Monthly premium due: 1st November 2024
  • Premium not paid (direct debit failed due to insufficient funds)
  • Policy lapsed on 15th November (2-week grace period expired)
  • Claim declined - no cover in force on diagnosis date

Prevention: Keep premiums current. Set up payment reminders.

2. Diagnosis Meets Policy Definition

Assessor compares:

  • Medical evidence provided
  • Policy definition of condition
  • All criteria must be met

Example:

Policy definition of heart attack requires:

  1. ✓ New ECG changes
  2. ✓ Cardiac enzyme rise
  3. ✓ Typical chest pain

Medical evidence shows:

  1. ✓ ECG: ST-segment elevation consistent with MI
  2. ✓ Troponin: Significantly elevated (850 ng/L)
  3. ✓ Patient history: Central crushing chest pain

Result: All three criteria met → Diagnosis meets definition → Claim proceeds

3. Condition Not Excluded

Checks for:

  • Pre-existing condition exclusions (if policy has waiting period)
  • Specifically excluded conditions (e.g., carcinoma in situ)
  • Exclusions due to non-disclosure at application

Pre-existing condition example:

Emma's cancer claim:

  • Policy started: 1st January 2023
  • Cancer diagnosed: 15th November 2024
  • Policy has 12-month pre-existing condition exclusion
  • Medical evidence shows: First GP visit for symptom was March 2022
  • Colonoscopy showed polyps: May 2022 (before policy started)
  • Polyps monitored but not disclosed on application
  • Question: Is this pre-existing?

Insurer's assessment:

  • Symptoms present before policy start
  • Medical investigations before policy start
  • Not disclosed on application
  • Claim declined for non-disclosure of pre-existing condition

If Emma had disclosed:

  • Insurer would have requested medical details at application
  • Likely outcome: Policy issued with exclusion for bowel conditions for 2-5 years
  • After exclusion period, full cover
  • Or: Policy declined at application stage if risk too high

Key learning: Always disclose all medical history at application, even seemingly minor issues.

4. Application Was Accurate

Assessor reviews:

  • Original application form
  • Answers to medical questions
  • Consistency with GP records

Looking for material non-disclosure:

  • Failure to disclose relevant medical history
  • Incorrect answers to questions
  • Omission of important information

Example:

Robert's stroke claim:

  • Policy application (2 years ago):
    • Question: "Have you had high blood pressure in the last 5 years?"
    • Answer: "No"
  • GP records show:
    • Blood pressure readings consistently 150/95+ for 3 years before application
    • Prescribed blood pressure medication 18 months before application
    • Regular monitoring for hypertension

Insurer's position:

  • Clear non-disclosure of material fact
  • If disclosed, policy would have been loaded (higher premium) or hypertension excluded
  • Claim declined for non-disclosure

Robert's potential recourse:

  • If GP diagnosed but Robert genuinely unaware (poor communication), may argue non-disclosure wasn't deliberate
  • Financial Ombudsman may consider individual circumstances
  • Outcome uncertain

Prevention: Be thorough and honest on application. If unsure, over-disclose rather than under-disclose.

Step 6: Additional Requirements

Sometimes assessor needs more information.

Common Additional Requests

Independent Medical Examination (IME)

When required:

  • Large claims (£500,000+)
  • Unclear diagnosis from records
  • Conflicting medical information
  • Condition severity in question

What happens:

  • Insurer arranges appointment with independent doctor (specialist in relevant field)
  • Usually at their medical centre or sometimes your home
  • Physical examination
  • Review of all medical records
  • Doctor prepares report for insurer

Timeline: 2-4 weeks to arrange, 1-2 weeks for report

Your rights:

  • Can bring someone with you
  • Can request different location if mobility issues
  • Can ask for copy of report

Example:

Lisa's MS claim:

  • Diagnosis confirmed by neurologist
  • Policy requires "neurological abnormalities persisting for at least 6 months"
  • Lisa diagnosed 7 months ago
  • Records unclear on severity of ongoing symptoms
  • IME requested:
    • Independent neurologist examines Lisa
    • Confirms ongoing neurological deficits
    • Report states: "Persistent right-sided weakness, impaired coordination, visual disturbances"
    • Claim approved based on IME confirmation

Further Specialist Reports

Why requested:

  • Initial reports don't fully address policy definition
  • Need specialist opinion on specific aspect
  • Prognosis unclear

Example:

David's cancer claim:

  • Diagnosed with prostate cancer
  • Policy excludes early-stage prostate cancer (T1a/T1b, Gleason 6 or below)
  • Initial pathology report unclear on staging
  • Further report requested: Detailed pathology review by specialist uropathologist
  • Result: Confirms T2a staging, Gleason 7
  • Claim approved (doesn't meet exclusion criteria)

Telephone Interview

Purpose:

  • Clarify aspects of claim
  • Understand timeline of symptoms and diagnosis
  • Fill gaps in written evidence

Tips for interview:

  • Be honest and consistent
  • Don't speculate - say "I don't remember" if unsure
  • Have medical timeline written out for reference
  • Keep answers concise and relevant

Step 7: Decision Notification

Insurer communicates their decision.

Claim Approved

What you receive:

  • Written approval letter
  • Confirmation of sum assured being paid
  • Payment timeline (usually 3-5 working days)
  • Tax information (claims are tax-free)
  • Policy termination confirmation
  • Information on continued support services (if available)

Example approval letter excerpt:

"We are pleased to confirm that we have approved your critical illness claim. Following our review of your medical evidence, we can confirm that your diagnosis of invasive breast cancer meets the definition of cancer under your policy.

Payment details:

  • Sum assured: £150,000
  • Payment date: 22nd November 2024
  • Bank account: ****1234

Your critical illness policy will terminate upon payment of this claim. However, your life insurance policy (if separate) remains in force.

The claim payment is tax-free and does not need to be declared to HMRC..."

Next steps:

  • Funds typically in account within 3-5 working days
  • No tax implications
  • Policy ends (unless buyback option - see separate guide)
  • Life insurance continues if separate policy

Claim Declined

Reasons for decline:

  1. Doesn't meet policy definition

    • Example: DCIS (Stage 0 cancer) when policy requires invasive cancer
  2. Pre-existing condition not disclosed

    • Condition present before policy start and not disclosed
  3. Policy not in force

    • Premiums not up to date on diagnosis date
  4. Non-disclosure at application

    • Failed to reveal material medical history
  5. Condition excluded

    • Falls under specific policy exclusions

What the letter includes:

  • Reason for decline
  • Which policy term/definition not met
  • Evidence reviewed
  • Right to appeal
  • Next steps

Example decline letter excerpt:

"Following our review of your claim, we regret to inform you that we are unable to accept your claim for critical illness benefit.

Reason for decline: Your diagnosis of ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) does not meet our policy definition of cancer. Our policy requires: 'A malignant tumour characterised by the uncontrolled growth and spread of malignant cells and the invasion of tissue.'

DCIS is classified as Stage 0 breast cancer and is pre-invasive (has not invaded surrounding tissue). As such, it does not meet the requirement for invasion.

Your rights: If you believe this decision is incorrect, you have the right to appeal. Please refer to our appeals process enclosed..."

Step 8: If Your Claim Is Declined

Don't accept decline without review - many declined claims are overturned on appeal.

Understanding the Decline

First step: Understand exactly why claim was declined

  1. Read decline letter carefully
  2. Request full file - insurer must provide all information they hold
  3. Identify the specific issue:
    • Definition not met?
    • Non-disclosure?
    • Pre-existing condition?
    • Missing evidence?

Gathering Counter-Evidence

If you believe decline is wrong:

Get Expert Medical Opinion

Scenario: Claim declined because diagnosis doesn't meet definition

Action:

  • Request second opinion from specialist
  • Ask specialist to address specific policy definition
  • Get written report confirming diagnosis meets criteria

Example:

Tom's heart attack claim declined:

  • Insurer says: "No typical chest pain reported"
  • Policy requires: ECG changes + Troponin rise + typical chest pain
  • Tom did have chest pain but described as "indigestion-like discomfort"
  • Cardiologist's report didn't use term "typical chest pain"

Tom's appeal:

  • Obtains report from cardiologist specifically addressing pain
  • Report states: "Patient's symptoms of central chest discomfort radiating to left arm are typical of myocardial infarction"
  • Decline overturned - chest pain was typical, just not initially described that way

Review Application for Errors

Scenario: Declined for non-disclosure

Check:

  • What exactly was asked on application?
  • What did you answer?
  • What insurer says you didn't disclose?
  • Was question ambiguous?
  • Did you reasonably interpret question differently?

Example:

Sarah's cancer claim declined:

  • Insurer: "You didn't disclose family history of cancer"
  • Application question: "Does anyone in your immediate family have cancer?"
  • Sarah answered: "No"
  • Insurer found: Mother had breast cancer 15 years ago
  • Sarah's position: Mother's cancer was 15 years ago, question used present tense ("has"), she interpreted as current diagnosis
  • Also: Sarah understood "immediate family" as children and spouse, not parents

Appeal: Question was ambiguous regarding:

  1. Timeframe (current vs. historical)
  2. Definition of "immediate family"

Outcome: Financial Ombudsman agreed question was ambiguous, overturn decline

Internal Appeals Process

Step 1: Submit Internal Appeal

Within: Usually 30-90 days of decline (check policy terms)

Include:

  1. Cover letter:

    • State you're appealing decline
    • Reference policy number and claim number
    • Summarise why decline is wrong
    • List supporting evidence attached
  2. Supporting evidence:

    • Additional medical reports
    • Expert opinions
    • Clarification letters
    • Any evidence addressing decline reason
  3. Request:

    • Full review by different assessor
    • Reconsideration of decision

Example appeal letter:

"I am writing to appeal the decline of my critical illness claim (Policy: L&G987654, Claim: CL12345).

My claim was declined on the basis that my diagnosis of Non-ST Elevation Myocardial Infarction (NSTEMI) does not meet your heart attack definition. However, I believe this decision is incorrect for the following reasons:

  1. Your policy definition requires 'death of heart muscle due to inadequate blood supply with new ECG changes, cardiac enzyme rise, and typical chest pain.' All three criteria were met:

    • ECG showed new T-wave inversion in leads V1-V4
    • Troponin level was elevated at 580 ng/L
    • I experienced typical central crushing chest pain
  2. NSTEMI is a recognised form of heart attack involving heart muscle death

  3. Attached is a letter from my cardiologist, Dr James Wilson, confirming my NSTEMI diagnosis and explaining how it meets your policy definition

I respectfully request that you reconsider your decline decision in light of this evidence..."

Timeline: Insurer should respond within 8 weeks

Outcomes:

  • Accept appeal: Claim approved and paid
  • Partial accept: Offer settlement (e.g., if some doubt, may offer 50-75% of sum assured)
  • Maintain decline: Still declined, but with more detailed explanation

Financial Ombudsman Service

If internal appeal unsuccessful:

Eligibility:

  • Insurer has issued "final response" letter
  • Or 8 weeks passed since appeal with no response
  • Claim within last 6 years

Process:

  1. Submit complaint to Ombudsman:

    • Free service
    • Online form or written complaint
    • Provide all correspondence and evidence
  2. Ombudsman reviews:

    • Independent assessment
    • Reviews all evidence
    • Not bound by strict policy terms (considers fairness)
    • Can request additional information from both parties
  3. Decision:

    • Uphold complaint: Insurer must pay claim (+ possible compensation)
    • Not uphold: Insurer's decline stands
    • Partial uphold: May order partial payment

Timeline:

  • Simple case: 3-6 months
  • Complex case: 6-12 months

Success rate:

  • Approximately 35-40% of critical illness complaints upheld or partially upheld

Example:

Emma's multiple sclerosis claim:

  • Declined: Symptoms hadn't persisted 6 months at time of claim (5.5 months)
  • Internal appeal: Declined (insurer strictly applied 6-month rule)
  • Ombudsman: Considered fairness
    • Emma diagnosed and claimed in good faith
    • Only 2 weeks short of 6-month requirement
    • Symptoms clearly permanent
    • Ombudsman decision: Claim should be paid - technical breach of 2 weeks unreasonable given clear diagnosis
  • Insurer ordered to pay: £120,000 + £200 compensation for distress

Key point: Ombudsman considers fairness, not just technical policy compliance.

Expert Tips for Successful Claims

1. Keep Excellent Records

From diagnosis onwards:

Medical appointments:

  • Dates and consultant names
  • Test dates and results
  • Treatment timelines

Insurance correspondence:

  • Every letter/email from insurer
  • Every phone call (date, time, person spoken to, what discussed)
  • All forms submitted (keep copies)

Medical evidence:

  • Discharge summaries given to you
  • Test results provided
  • Consultant letters

Why: If dispute arises, contemporaneous records invaluable

2. Respond Promptly

Insurer requests information:

  • Respond within stated timeframe
  • If need extension, request it before deadline
  • Don't let correspondence sit unanswered

Delays cause:

  • Extended claim process
  • Potential claim decline for non-cooperation
  • Frustration and stress

3. Be Honest and Consistent

In all communications:

  • Tell the truth
  • Be consistent across all statements
  • If you don't remember, say so (don't guess)
  • Don't exaggerate or minimise

Inconsistencies raise red flags:

  • Trigger more detailed investigations
  • Can jeopardise entire claim
  • May be interpreted as fraud

4. Get Professional Help if Needed

When to use adviser:

  • Claim is complex
  • Substantial sum assured (£250k+)
  • Initial decline
  • Medical evidence unclear
  • Insurer requesting lots of additional information

Adviser can:

  • Coordinate evidence gathering
  • Liaise with insurer
  • Present claim optimally
  • Appeal on your behalf
  • Escalate to Ombudsman if needed

Cost:

  • Many advisers provide claims support free (already paid via commission)
  • Some charge £500-£2,000 for claims support
  • Usually worth it for large or complex claims

5. Understand Your Policy

Before you claim:

  • Read policy document
  • Understand exact definition of your condition
  • Check waiting periods
  • Know what evidence is required

Prevents:

  • Claiming for non-covered condition
  • Disappointment from inevitable decline
  • Wasted time and stress

Tax Treatment of Claims

Good news: Critical illness payouts are tax-free

Income Tax

Claim payment:

  • No income tax payable
  • Not treated as income
  • Don't declare on tax return

Example:

  • Claim payout: £200,000
  • Income tax due: £0

Capital Gains Tax

Not applicable:

  • Critical illness payout is not a capital gain
  • No CGT implications

Inheritance Tax (IHT)

If policy in trust:

  • Payout outside your estate
  • No IHT implications
  • Passes directly to beneficiaries

If policy not in trust:

  • Payout becomes part of your estate
  • If you die within 7 years, may be subject to IHT
  • Usually not an issue as most critical illness policyholders survive and use funds

State Benefits

May affect means-tested benefits:

  • Universal Credit
  • Housing Benefit
  • Pension Credit
  • Council Tax reduction

£200,000 lump sum could disqualify you from benefits based on capital limits

Mitigation:

  • Spend on mortgage/debts immediately
  • Transfer to spouse if they need care
  • Set aside for specific expenses (home adaptations, etc.)
  • Seek benefits advice if you receive means-tested support

Using Your Payout

Once funds received, common uses:

1. Pay Off Mortgage/Debts

  • Most common use
  • Reduces financial burden during illness
  • Provides security for family

2. Fund Treatment

  • Private medical care
  • Experimental treatments not available on NHS
  • Access to specialists
  • Alternative therapies

3. Replace Income

  • If unable to work
  • Cover living expenses
  • Maintain family lifestyle

4. Home Adaptations

  • Wheelchair access
  • Stairlifts
  • Accessible bathroom
  • Ground-floor bedroom

5. Prepare for Future

  • Build emergency fund
  • Increase life insurance (if still available)
  • Set aside for children's education
  • Invest for long-term

Financial advice recommended:

  • Lump sum is one-time payment
  • Need to make it last
  • Tax-efficient strategies
  • Ensure money works for you

Summary: Keys to Successful Claim

Know your policy - Understand what's covered and policy definitions
Notify promptly - Tell insurer as soon as diagnosed
Complete forms thoroughly - Provide all requested information
Respond quickly - Don't delay replies to insurer requests
Keep records - Document everything
Be honest - Accuracy and consistency crucial
Use support - Adviser, insurer support services, medical professionals
Don't give up - Many declined claims successfully appealed

Timeline expectations:

  • Standard claim: 6-12 weeks
  • Complex claim: 3-6 months
  • Disputed claim: 6-18 months (with Ombudsman)

Most claims are approved:

  • Industry approval rate: 92-95%
  • Declines often for technical reasons (doesn't meet definition, excluded condition)
  • Many declines can be appealed successfully

Get Claims Support

Making a critical illness claim during an already difficult time can be overwhelming. Professional support can make the process smoother and improve success rates.

We Can Help:

Claims guidance - Navigate the process step-by-step
Evidence coordination - Help gather necessary medical evidence
Insurer liaison - Communicate with insurer on your behalf
Appeals support - Challenge unfair declines
Ombudsman representation - Escalate to Financial Ombudsman if needed

Get expert claims support - we'll help ensure your claim is processed fairly and efficiently.

Note: This guide provides general information about critical illness claims processes. Specific policy terms and insurer procedures vary. Always check your policy documents and contact your insurer for definitive information about your specific claim.

Need Specialist Help?

This guide provides general information. For personalised advice on your specific situation, speak to one of our specialist mortgage advisers.

Free Mortgage Tools

Use our free calculators to plan your mortgage.

Find a Local Adviser

Speak to a specialist mortgage adviser near you.

Verified Client Reviews

Independently authenticated via Reviews.io. Only real clients can leave feedback.

Loading verified client reviews...