Quick Answer

How Should I Compare Mortgages?

Reviewed by Jay SabineCeMAP, Cert CII (MP)29 years experience
CeMAP Professional - The London Institute of Banking & FinanceCert CII Member - Chartered Insurance Institute

Calculate total cost over your expected term (payments + fees - cashback), not just the interest rate. Use a broker to search the whole market.

Comparing mortgages on rate alone is a common mistake. Two mortgages with the same rate can have vastly different total costs due to fees. To compare properly, calculate the total you'll pay over your intended term: multiply the monthly payment by the number of months in your deal, add any product fees, valuation fees, and legal costs, then subtract any cashback. This gives you the true cost of each deal. On a £200,000 mortgage, a 0.1% rate difference is £200/year - so a £1,000 fee needs 5 years to 'pay back' through the lower rate. Most people remortgage after 2-5 years, making fees highly relevant.

Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.

Key Points

  • 1Calculate total cost, not just rate
  • 2Include all fees in comparison
  • 3Consider your expected term (2, 5, 10 years)
  • 4Factor in cashback offers
  • 5Comparison sites show limited market
  • 6Brokers access exclusive deals

Eligibility Criteria

  • Know your deposit/equity percentage
  • Understand your credit profile
  • Have income documentation ready
  • Know your property type and value
  • Decide on fixed vs variable preference

Typical Timeframe

Comparing mortgages yourself takes hours. A broker can search thousands of deals in minutes using specialist software, then present you with the best options for your circumstances.

Next Steps

  1. 1Gather your financial information
  2. 2Check your credit report
  3. 3Calculate your loan-to-value ratio
  4. 4Speak to a whole-of-market broker
  5. 5Compare total costs not just rates

Why This Matters for Your Mortgage

Understanding these details helps you make informed decisions during the mortgage process. Every element of your application—from deposits to documentation—affects your approval chances and the rates you can access.

Lenders assess applications holistically, weighing multiple factors together. Knowing what they look for allows you to present the strongest possible application. This is particularly important for non-standard situations where lender criteria varies significantly.

Ready to discuss your options?

FCA regulated advice tailored to your situation

Related Questions

For more detailed information about this topic, visit our comprehensive guide:

Mortgage Hub
CeMAP Professional - The London Institute of Banking & FinanceCert CII Member - Chartered Insurance Institute
Jay Sabine
CeMAP, Cert CII (MP)
29 Years Experience

Content reviewed: January 2026

CeMAP awarded by The London Institute of Banking & Finance. Cert CII (MP) awarded by the Chartered Insurance Institute.

What to Compare

Interest Rate

The headline rate. Important but not everything - a lower rate with high fees can cost more overall.

Product Fee

Typically £0-£2,000. Can be added to loan but you'll pay interest on it. Critical for true cost comparison.

Early Repayment Charges

Typically 1-5% of loan if you leave early. Important if you might move or overpay significantly.

Cashback

Some deals offer £250-£1,000 cashback. Subtract this from total cost. May offset higher rates.

Free Valuation/Legal

Some lenders include free valuation (£300+ value) or legal fees for remortgages. Factor into comparison.

SVR After Deal

What rate you'll pay if you don't remortgage. Usually 4-7%. Set a reminder to switch before deal ends.

Total Cost Example

Comparing two mortgages on a £250,000 loan over 25 years, 5-year fixed:

Deal A: 4.0% rate, £999 fee

  • Monthly payment: £1,319
  • 5-year payments: £79,140
  • Product fee: £999
  • Total 5-year cost: £80,139

Deal B: 4.2% rate, no fee

  • Monthly payment: £1,345
  • 5-year payments: £80,700
  • Product fee: £0
  • Total 5-year cost: £80,700

Result: Deal A saves £561 over 5 years despite the £999 fee. But on a smaller mortgage, the fee-free deal might win.

People Also Ask

Verified Client Reviews

Independently authenticated via Reviews.io. Only real clients can leave feedback.

Loading verified client reviews...